Virginia Prisons Accountability Committee

Friday, November 20, 2026

WE REJECT LYNN NOVICKS' CRIME AND PUNISHMENT PBS DOCUMENTARY PART II By William Thorpe

Pictures are taken from the internet and are used for illustrative purposes only
Towards "that thief in the night" ends, the human condition will deploy, that proverbial "kitchen sink" sophistry straight-faced and, haplessly LYNN NOVICK embodies it in the slant, she long handled spoon feeds us in her CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA DOCUMENTARY ON PBS. Notwithstanding the schizophrenic posit of the JAMES BALDWIN and WILLIAM F. BUCKLEY Debates on the basis of "The American Dream", there isn't anyone even in a momentary lapse of reason, in its insanity legal context, existing the unity of the sovereignty and dehumanization of the socio-person, that will subjectively deny the intrinsic corruption of the Nations establishment, with that rank and fetid, Period apology. That we typically experience as the noxious Thought of the Intellectual-liberalism of Reaction and it's Conservatism, yet that is what we encounter coming out of Lynn Novick, when she defends savagery and barbarism with, (and I paraphrase) that we should not and cannot judge the actions and behavior of the historical depictions of Justice and Punishment in her documentary by contemporary standards or in other words, that pathetic, dotardly farcical and fraudulent Period apology. The Period apology as it stands is even more malevolent than the deeds it exist to defend. It turns everything on its head. From savagery, barbarism, the thief in the night, rape, pillage, genocide, to the treachery of Esau being robbed of his birthright, to identify a few of our human capabilities as mere events that shouldn't bear our as critiqued modern or contemporary opprobrium. Even as we affirm and legitimize the contemporary and modern presence with the celebration of that same past or historical events, which the likes of Lynn Novick declare irreproachable of indictment and castigation. The Period apology has a presumptive bias, that is aerated by complicity. Ms. Novick, reveals the complicity by peppering and sprinkling the morality verbiage throughout her documentary, with for example (and I paraphrase),the American Imprisonment scheme is a result of the morality and benevolence of the "Founding Fathers" who by being horrified at the state of punishment resolved its reform. She says this with a straight face, that we are supposed to swallow it, that those same "Founding Fathers", who were so corrupt,that they couldn't distinguish what is a Human Being, had any real capacity to theorize "reform" more or less practice it apart and independent of their idealistic self-interest. What Ms. Novick considers in her documentary as contradictions are in fact fully developed and mature antagonisms. Her failure to recognize this fact are the inevitable and inexorable conclusions of her Founding Father morality footsie thinking. Because contrary to the universe of gambits employed by status quo self-interest, towards the ends of ensuring our, The People's conscious and unconscious complicity, the implacable dictatorship of intent of the Justice Infrastructure and its imprisonment scheme, reveals the self-interest and intention, with Jurisprudence. See: STATE CREATED DANGER evidencing contradictions glossed over by Ms. Novick's documentary (1) DESHANEY v. WINNEBAGO COUNTY DEP'T OF SOCIAL SERVICE 488 U.S.189 [ State didn't have any duty to protect minor from imminency of harm from Father]TOWN OF CASTLE ROCK v. GONZALES 545 U.S.748 [police do not have any duty to protect or act] STERLING v. CITY OF JACKSON 159 F.4th 361, 190 F.4th 391 [no Constitutional Right to Clean Water and Government Officials can legally lie to you] The above are examples of the "morality" Lynn Novick sur-imposes on consequences of political-economy interests. Ms. Novick ignores the self-evident critique, that by products are not indicative of altruistic intent.

By William Thorpe

William Thorpe Virginia exiled me to the Texas prison system. I'm solitary confined at the Wainwright Unit and if you feel any kinda way about this work contact me by Securus email using the Texas prison number #2261982


Thursday, November 19, 2026

ON LYNN NOVICK

Pictures are taken from the internet and are used for illustrative purposes only

The VAPAC post,“WE REJECT LYNN NOVICK'S SLANT OF HER CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA DOCUMENTARY ON PBS” by William Thorpe, is a critique of filmmaker Lynn Novick's PBS documentary Crime and Punishment in America.

Main argument

Thorpe argues that while Novick may be well-intentioned, her documentary presents what he considers a selective and incomplete history of crime and punishment in the United States. He contends that the film accepts conventional ideas about justice, public safety, and criminality without adequately examining the deeper economic and political forces that shaped American punishment systems.

Key themes

  • Critique of historical narratives: Thorpe compares Novick's approach to what he sees as mythmaking in traditional American history, using Captain John Smith as an example of a figure whose story has been heavily embellished.
  • Justice as social control: He argues that punishment systems have historically been driven less by morality, rehabilitation, or public safety than by economic interests, labor demands, and power structures
  • Slavery and imprisonment: Thorpe asserts that the history of American imprisonment cannot be understood apart from the nation's history of slavery and dehumanization. He criticizes the documentary for not exploring those connections more deeply
  • Challenge to reform narratives: Rather than viewing the criminal justice system as a flawed institution seeking improvement, he presents it as fundamentally rooted in economic and political control.

Despite his criticisms, Thorpe says the documentary has one redeeming quality: it encourages critique and discussion of the prison and justice system. He views that opportunity for public scrutiny as the work's principal value.

In one sentence: Thorpe argues that Novick's documentary critiques mass incarceration but still stops short of confronting what he sees as the deeper historical roots of punishment in slavery, labor exploitation, and state power.

1. Distrust of Liberal Reform Narratives

Thorpe is not merely criticizing Novick's documentary. The deeper target is what many prison abolitionists call "reformist reform."

His argument appears to be:

  • The problem is not that prisons have drifted from their mission.
  • The problem is that prisons were designed around social control from the beginning.
  • Therefore, documentaries focused on improving the system may obscure the nature of the system itself.

That attitude is common among abolitionist thinkers nationally, particularly those influenced by Angela Davis, Ruth Wilson Gilmore, Mariame Kaba, and other prison-industrial-complex critics.

2. Virginia's Historical Context Is Present Beneath the Surface

Although the article discusses a national documentary, the lens feels distinctly Virginian.

Virginia contains:

  • some of the oldest prisons in America,
  • a long history of convict labor,
  • the legacy of slavery and plantation economics,
  • continuing controversy surrounding Red Onion and Wallens Ridge.

Thorpe repeatedly returns to the idea that punishment systems cannot be separated from slavery and economic exploitation.

That argument resonates with a growing body of Virginia-focused prison criticism, especially among incarcerated writers and advocates who see the state's modern prison system as an extension of older systems of labor and social hierarchy.

3. A Challenge to the "Crime" Frame Itself

Most mainstream criminal-justice discussions start with crime and then ask:

How should society respond?

Thorpe appears to reverse the question:

Why does society define certain populations as criminal in the first place?

This is a much more structural critique.

Rather than debating sentencing, prison conditions, or rehabilitation, he is interrogating the institution itself.

That places the essay closer to abolitionist theory than conventional reform politics.

4. Evidence of an Undercurrent?

I would say yes, but not necessarily a majority view.

What the essay reveals is an undercurrent that has become increasingly visible during the last decade:

  • skepticism toward traditional criminal-justice reform;
  • greater emphasis on structural causes of incarceration;
  • linking imprisonment to race, labor, and economic power;
  • distrust of media portrayals that present institutions as fundamentally benevolent but flawed.

In academic circles and activist networks, these arguments are no longer fringe. They are now part of a substantial national conversation.

5. What Makes Thorpe's Perspective Distinct

Many abolitionist writers come from universities, nonprofits, or legal advocacy organizations.

Thorpe's writing carries something different:

  • the perspective of long-term incarceration,
  • direct experience with Virginia's prison system,
  • suspicion of narratives created by outside observers,
  • emphasis on lived experience over institutional storytelling.

That creates a recurring theme throughout much of his writing:

"Who gets to tell the story of imprisonment?"

The Novick critique is arguably less about Lynn Novick herself than about authority, representation, and narrative ownership. Thorpe appears to be arguing that even sympathetic filmmakers can unintentionally reproduce the assumptions of the institutions they seek to critique.

 Overall Assessment

The deepest "gist" of the essay is not simply "the documentary got it wrong."

It is:

American punishment is rooted in historical systems of domination, and narratives that portray incarceration primarily as a policy problem rather than a structural feature of power will inevitably miss the heart of the issue.

That position reflects a genuine and growing current within prison abolitionist thought nationally, while also carrying the particular imprint of Virginia's prison landscape and Thorpe's own experience within it. It is not necessarily representative of the majority of Virginians, but it is representative of a serious, intellectually coherent strand of prison critique that has gained influence in both activist and academic circles over the past two decades.

William Thorpe delivers a forceful critique of filmmaker Lynn Novick's PBS documentary Crime and Punishment in America, arguing that it presents an overly sympathetic and historically apologetic view of America's punishment system. 

The central argument is that Novick employs what Thorpe calls a "period apology," meaning the idea that historical practices of punishment and injustice should not be judged by modern moral standards. Thorpe rejects this approach, contending that it excuses brutality, oppression, and systemic abuses by treating them as products of their time rather than manifestations of enduring power structures. 

Thorpe is especially critical of the documentary's portrayal of the Founding Fathers as reformers motivated by morality and benevolence. He argues instead that America's justice and prison systems were built around political and economic self-interest rather than humanitarian ideals.

A major theme of the essay is the distinction between what Novick describes as "contradictions" in American justice and what Thorpe sees as fundamental antagonisms built into the system itself. He argues the prison and justice apparatus operates according to an entrenched "dictatorship of intent" that prioritizes state power over human welfare. 

To support this position, Thorpe cites several court decisions, including DeShaney v. Winnebago County, Town of Castle Rock v. Gonzales, and Sterling v. City of Jackson, which he presents as evidence that government institutions often have no affirmative legal duty to protect individuals from harm. He argues these cases undermine narratives that portray state institutions as fundamentally benevolent. 

Key Takeaway

The post is not primarily a review of Novick's documentary. Rather, it uses the documentary as a vehicle to advance a broader critique of American political power, jurisprudence, and imprisonment. Thorpe's position is that the prison system should be understood as an expression of state interests and social control, not as a flawed but fundamentally humanitarian reform project. 

By vapac

William Thorpe Virginia exiled me to the Texas prison system. I'm solitary confined at the Wainwright Unit and if you feel any kinda way about this work contact me by Securus email using the Texas prison number #2261982


Wednesday, November 18, 2026

WE REJECT LYNN NOVICK'S SLANT OF HER CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA DOCUMENTARY ON PBS By William Thorpe

Pictures are taken from the internet and are used for illustrative purposes only

Is Lynn Novick well intended with her work: CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA, airing on PBS? That is not the issue, what however is, is whether the work is actually doing what Lynn Novick claimed as intent on the November 16, 2026 episode of FRESH AIR. Okay let me frame where I'm coming from with this. So the historical personality, the invader-colonizer CAPTAIN JOHN SMITH of Virginia's JAMESTOWN, despite his prominence in Virginia and the Nations origin narrative has been characterized and described by writers of varied scholarship as, ALLAN BRINKLEY, NANCY ISENBERG, IBRAM X. KENDI and JAMES MICHENER from being an "exaggerator," "a self-promoter",(and I paraphrase), a tall tale teller," a liar" and as MICHENER put it in one of his seminal works, "CHESAPEAKE", CAPTAIN JOHN SMITH, defended his concoctions and fabrications with (and I paraphrase), if he had the opportunity, that is what he'd have done. Now why am I juxtaposing critique of Ms. Novick's CRIME and PUNISHMENT work with one of the Nations infamous sensationalist, because her narrative is in its vein. The situation isn't that Ms. Novick is being perfidious, or betraying and undercutting the reform polemic and critique of the Nations and subsequently Virginia's Imprisonment scheme, with her slant, but that is the issue, it's a slant. What Ms. Novick is nonetheless accomplishing is a continuation of the selectivity bias determining the convention of our understanding of deviance, criminality and the ensuing punishment, by ignoring and glossing over the fundamental critique of the dictatorship of intent of the Justice Infrastructure, which it has a bias. So we can swallow that proverbial concoction a la Captain John Smith on that long handled spoon assuming, JUSTICE is a blindfolded feminine form draped in Athenian garb, pursuing that other blindfolded unbiased Social-Contract presumptive "public safety", while in a stupor a la Ms. Novick we, ignore that a history of Crime and Punishment in America, as formulated by her scholarship slant is in itself a fraudulent undertaking, unless she is ready and willing to remove slants, qualifications, biases and its most obscene form, the genocidal context and its period apology from analysis of human conditional behavior. Because what we will encounter is, crime and punishment has nothing to do with "repairing harm" and a purported "public safety" objectivity and even its social control purpose is marginal, but we will stand face to face with the naked and unmasked visage of compelling the proximity of labor in its specific purpose of qualifying that quantification of the business of human existence. Prior to the dismantling of chattel slavery, there wasn't a population boom in the imprisoned, because imprisonment was incompatible with the political-economy demanding the creation of chattel slavery. Yes,the infliction of pain and suffering on specifically the non enslaved and indentured socio-person of Colonial North America existed and was present for any number of purported violations and it proves that the Justice application cared less about any assigned higher and civilized morality than it was about realizing the investor anticipations of their North American i.e Virginia investments. These are the rocks Lynn Novick with her Crime and Punishment Documentary, should have turned over. We don't need another revision by omission of the Nations morality and wholesomeness, a pompom waving Hi Mom grinning visage, when the Nations DNA is a hexagon of dehumanization regardless of its cutting of the nose to spite the face character. Does Ms. Novick's work have a redeeming quality yes, CRITIQUE.

By William Thorpe

William Thorpe Virginia exiled me to the Texas prison system. I'm solitary confined at the Wainwright Unit and if you feel any kinda way about this work contact me by Securus email using the Texas prison number #2261982

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

MARIE ANTOINETTE AND HOLDING THE VIRGINIA PRISON OFFICIAL ACCOUNTABLE

Pictures are taken from the internet and are used for illustrative purposes only

This post argues that prison reform is fundamentally tied to broader democratic and social struggles, and that meaningful change happens when ordinary people organize and act collectively. According to William Thorpe, efforts to hold Virginia prison officials accountable cannot be separated from larger questions about power, citizenship, and the social contract.

Main points

  • Thorpe's central claim is that the will of the people ultimately outweighs entrenched institutions and political power. He frames this as the enduring meaning of "of, by, and for the people."

  • He uses two political developments as examples:

    1. A 27-second campaign ad in Mississippi's 2026 U.S. Senate race.
    2. Virginia voters' approval of restoring voting rights to formerly imprisoned Virginians.
  • Thorpe argues that both events demonstrate how long-standing injustices and political contradictions can be challenged through organizing and voter action rather than being accepted as permanent conditions.

The Mississippi example

Thorpe highlights a Senate campaign in which an incumbent senator's remarks about rising meat prices were turned against her in a short social media ad. He says challenger Scott Colom's campaign distilled the issue into a simple message: "Pick another senator." Thorpe presents the election result as evidence that voters can reject leaders they believe have become disconnected from ordinary people.

The Virginia example

The post places even greater emphasis on Virginia's vote to restore voting rights to formerly incarcerated people. Thorpe describes this as a rejection of a long-standing exclusion of ex-prisoners from full civic participation and as an affirmation that formerly imprisoned people remain part of "the People."

The lesson for prison accountability

Thorpe's practical takeaway is straightforward:

Prison reform and accountability are not achieved merely through criticism or moral arguments. They require sustained organization, public engagement, and political action.

He concludes that prisoners and former prisoners should be viewed as members of the broader community, and that successful prison reform depends on the same kind of collective organizing that produces electoral and social change.

One-sentence summary

The post argues that recent electoral victories in Mississippi and Virginia show that organized citizens can overcome entrenched political systems, and that the same principle should guide efforts to hold Virginia prison officials accountable and advance prison reform.

By vapac



Monday, November 16, 2026

WHAT A 27 SECOND CAMPAIGN VIDEO IN MISSISSIPPI'S 2026 U.S. SENATORIAL RACE ALONG WITH THE 11/3/26, VOTING OF URBAN VIRGINIA, RESTORING VOTING RIGHTS TO THE EX IMPRISONED VIRGINIAN TEACHES US IN OUR WORK OF HOLDING THE VIRGINIA PRISON OFFICIAL ACCOUNTABLE By William Thorpe

Pictures are taken from the internet and are used for illustrative purposes only
That, everything and I mean everything is subordinate to the dictatorship of intention and WILL of The People. Meaning that condensed, "OF, BY AND FOR THE PEOPLE", despite being buffeted by contradictions and insidiousness, then used and abused endures. I BEGIN: My work and focus is reform of Virginia's imprisonment scheme by holding the Virginia Prison Official accountable. In it's labor it might seem and come across that I'm connecting disparate elements that on the surface have not much in common with Prison and Imprisonment scheme issues, but the reality is there isn't an aspect and formulation of our human condition and as it relates to us, Virginia's Social-Contract construct, that isn't exposing the fundamental antagonism of the imprisonment scheme as applied. And I'm not trying to so in other words you the reader to death, but in other words, there isn't a fact of the Social-Contract, not just Virginia's, that isn't tango-ing with the imprisonment dialectic. I have delved a bit more comprehensively into that aspect in my other works, but now I want to speak more to the organizational and practical realities of the work of holding the Virginia Prison Official accountable or the Accountability-Function of Virginia's governance. I titled this work, WHAT A 27 SECOND CAMPAIGN VIDEO IN MISSISSIPPI'S 2026 U.S. SENATORIAL RACE ALONG WITH THE 11/3/2026, VOTING OF URBAN VIRGINIA RESTORING VOTING RIGHTS TO THE EX IMPRISONED VIRGINIAN TEACHES US IN OUR WORK OF HOLDING THE VIRGINIA PRISON OFFICIAL ACCOUNTABLE, because both occasions are momentous. Not because the People or the socio-person displayed affirmation of progressive aspirations, but because the action taken by the People in both instances, revealed that resolving the contradictions and insidiousness developed and imposed by monolith brains and hearts isn't an insurmountable pre-ordained, apocalyptic revelation of the unity of "good" and "evil". But is just another proof of organizational-diligence and practice. The 27 second campaign video in Mississippi's 2026 U.S. Senatorial race, was a simple testament to the folly of hubris at the expense of the respect and dignity of the People. You see the incumbent Senator,(a Republican who lost to the 140+ year history making election of a Black Mississippian) in response to the legitimate issue of the price of meat, channeled Marie Antoinette's," let 'em eat cake" quip in another not dissimilar circumstance of pre-revolutionary France, from Trump and the Republican Party in the U.S. 2026, mid-term elections and I paraphrase, there are many types of protein, so pick a protein. Which the history making Scott Colom's Campaign instantly seized and turned into a Social Media Ad, 27 seconds long but covered the 140+ year absence of a Black Senator representing Mississippi, with the simple commonsense, PICK ANOTHER SENATOR, which Black, White, Hispanic, Asian and Native American Mississippians on 11/3/2026 agreed with and done. So in response to another 150 year contradiction and insidiousness that incorrigibly continued the dehumanization of a demographic of the Virginia socio-person, the 11/3/2026 Virginia Urban electorate, those voting Democratic, enlightened, Progressive and pursuing the UNITY OF THE PEOPLE, Spoke with a 56.5% majority to restore voting rights to the ex imprisoned Virginian. The point is simple: the Virginia Prisoner is a unit of the People. The work of Prison Reform requires organizational-diligence.

By William Thorpe

William Thorpe Virginia exiled me to the Texas prison system. I'm solitary confined at the Wainwright Unit and if you feel any kinda way about this work contact me by Securus email using the Texas prison number #2261982.